Marc’s Top 10 Stage

All-time favorites. Click a card for the official site or primary info.
#1
Wicked (2003 Musical)
Creators: Music & Lyrics: Stephen Schwartz · Book: Winnie Holzman
Broadway Gross: $1,794,158,470
Times seen: 4 (San Francisco 2009, San Francisco 2009, Singapore 2012, San Francisco 2013)

Before Dorothy, two young women meet in Oz—one born with emerald skin, the other impossibly popular—and a notorious rivalry turns into an unlikely friendship. A blockbuster score (“Defying Gravity”) powers a story about perspective, fate, and who gets to be called ‘wicked.’

Film Part One (2024) opened #1 and finished with ~$756M worldwide; scored 10 Oscar nominations including Cynthia Erivo (Lead) and Ariana Grande (Supporting), plus a Golden Globes ‘Cinematic and Box Office Achievement’ win.
#2
The Phantom of the Opera (1988 Musical)
Creators: Music: Andrew Lloyd Webber · Lyrics: Charles Hart (addl. lyrics: Richard Stilgoe) · Book: Lloyd Webber & Stilgoe
Broadway Gross: $1,364,632,622
Times seen: 3 (San Francisco 199?, San Francisco 199?, San Francisco 199?)

A masked genius haunts the Paris Opera House and becomes obsessed with a young soprano. Romantic, gothic, and grand, it’s Broadway’s longest-running show ever—its chandelier drop and soaring melodies defined a generation of theater.

Broadway run ended 2023 after 35 years.
#3 (tie)
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child — Part One (2018 Play)
Creators: By Jack Thorne · Story by J.K. Rowling, Jack Thorne & John Tiffany
Broadway Gross: $430,000,000
Times seen: 1 (New York City 2019)

Nineteen years after Hogwarts, a new generation grapples with legacy, time travel, and the weight of family names. The staging is a practical-magic marvel with illusions that feel impossible in real time.

Originally presented in two parts on Broadway.
#3 (tie)
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child — Part Two (2018 Play)
Creators: By Jack Thorne · Story by J.K. Rowling, Jack Thorne & John Tiffany
Broadway Gross: $430,000,000
Times seen: 1 (New York City 2019)

The story’s emotional crescendo—friendships tested, timelines bent, and a finale that lands both spectacle and heart. Together with Part One, it set weekly box office records for a play.

U.S. production reworked into a single-part version in 2021.
#5
The Lion King (1997 Musical)
Creators: Music: Elton John · Lyrics: Tim Rice · Book: Roger Allers & Irene Mecchi
Broadway Gross: $2,116,021,636
Times seen: 3 (New York City 2002, San Francisco 2004, San Jose 2015)

A coming-of-age epic transformed by Taymor’s puppetry and stagecraft. It’s Broadway’s all-time top grosser, marrying pop anthems with breathtaking design and movement.

Broadway’s highest-grossing production ever—over $2.1B on Broadway alone—with more than 100M people worldwide; Julie Taymor became the first woman to win the Tony for Best Direction of a Musical.
#6
The Boys from Syracuse (1938 Musical)
Creators: Music: Richard Rodgers · Lyrics: Lorenz Hart · Book: George Abbott
Broadway Gross: n/a or not consolidated
Times seen: 4 (San Mateo 1983, San Mateo 1983, San Mateo 1983, San Francisco 1995)

A zany, tuneful Shakespeare romp (The Comedy of Errors) with classic Rodgers & Hart wit. Mistaken identities multiply; melodies stick.

Opened at the Alvin Theatre on Nov. 23, 1938; regarded as the first Broadway musical based on Shakespeare (The Comedy of Errors), later adapted to film in 1940 and revived in 1963 and 2002.
#7
Hamilton (2015 Musical)
Creators: Book/Music/Lyrics: Lin-Manuel Miranda
Broadway Gross: $1,090,421,205
Times seen: 1 (San Francisco 2017)

The American Revolution reimagined through hip-hop, R&B, and show-tune craft. A cultural quake about ambition, legacy, and who tells your story.

Record 16 Tony nominations and 11 wins (2016), plus the 2016 Pulitzer Prize for Drama—cementing its status as a cultural landmark.
#8
Aladdin (2014 Musical)
Creators: Music: Alan Menken · Lyrics: Howard Ashman & Tim Rice · Book/Lyrics: Chad Beguelin
Broadway Gross: $737,302,614
Times seen: 1 (San Francisco 2017)

A lavish Disney spectacle powered by a wish-granting Genie, big tap numbers, and Menken earworms. Joy-forward musical comedy.

Original Broadway Genie James Monroe Iglehart won the 2014 Tony Award for Best Featured Actor in a Musical (and later joined Broadway’s Hamilton cast).
#9
Beautiful: The Carole King Musical (2014 Musical)
Creators: Book: Douglas McGrath · Songs by Carole King & Gerry Goffin; Barry Mann & Cynthia Weil
Broadway Gross: n/a or not consolidated
Times seen: 1 (San Francisco 2013)

A biographical jukebox musical tracking Carole King’s path from Brill Building hitmaker to Tapestry icon, with knock-out arrangements of classics.

World premiere in SF (2013), Broadway 2014–2019.
#10
The Book of Mormon (2011 Musical)
Creators: Book/Music/Lyrics: Trey Parker, Robert Lopez & Matt Stone
Broadway Gross: $860,390,418
Times seen: 1 (San Francisco 2012)

A gleefully irreverent, surprisingly warm buddy-mission musical with giant laughs and even bigger hooks—satire with a showbiz grin.

From South Park creators Trey Parker & Matt Stone and EGOT-winning composer Robert Lopez (Frozen, Coco, Avenue Q), it became one of Broadway’s most successful modern musicals.